banana
True Banana
Zoro > Law
Posts: 1,577
|
Post by banana on Oct 21, 2015 23:07:52 GMT -5
Mine (I've only played BO1 and up and this is just a multiplayer ranking):
BO3: Seems promising
BO2: Perfect besides shotguns and the snipers should've had .05 less ads but whatever.
MW3: Maps were cool to me and so was the gun balance. Scar, Acr, G36c, PP90, Mp7, P90, L86. Shotguns were alright. Dat sniper ads tho.
AW: Exos aren't bad (besides when sniping), just needed better maps. Parliament, Kremlin, Detroit and Bio Lab are examples of how the maps should be made in the future. Variants were a cool idea but there needs to be less of them.
Shotguns suck. Sniper ads sucks.
BO1: Perfect perk tier 2 + nuketown and firing range but had bad anti lag and gun clones. Shotguns were alright. Sniper ads sucks.
Ghosts: Maps were bad besides Freight and Strikezone. Shotguns were alright. Dat sniper ads time tho.
|
|
banana
True Banana
Zoro > Law
Posts: 1,577
|
Post by banana on Oct 21, 2015 23:12:27 GMT -5
dang wrong section, how do i move this?
|
|
|
|
Post by ChloeB42 (Alexcalibur42) on Oct 22, 2015 2:15:22 GMT -5
Just delete it and repost in hey guy
|
|
|
|
Post by kylet357 on Oct 22, 2015 2:39:27 GMT -5
Mine (I've only played BO1 and up and this is just a multiplayer ranking):BO3: Seems promising BO2: Perfect besides shotguns and the snipers should've had .05 less ads but whatever. MW3: Maps were cool to me and so was the gun balance. Scar, Acr, G36c, PP90, Mp7, P90, L86. Shotguns were alright. Dat sniper ads tho. AW: Exos aren't bad (besides when sniping), just needed better maps. Parliament, Kremlin, Detroit and Bio Lab are examples of how the maps should be made in the future. Variants were a cool idea but there needs to be less of them. Shotguns suck. Sniper ads sucks. BO1: Perfect perk tier 2 + nuketown and firing range but had bad anti lag and gun clones. Shotguns were alright. Sniper ads sucks. Ghosts: Maps were bad besides Freight and Strikezone. Shotguns were alright. Dat sniper ads time tho. 1. BO2 Probably the best CoD game in the series for me. The campaign is good, introducing a non-linear storyline, the characters are great (I will maintain that Menendez is the best character we've had in the series so far). Multiplayer introduced a few new mechanics, and the gun balance (outside of shotguns at least) was pretty good. The maps were good, but I will always say that they could have been bigger. And of course, Zombies was excellent.  2. MW3 I won't deny it, this game was incredibly fun. The campaign wasn't great and spec-ops was laughable, but the MP was awesome. It was mostly due to the Specialist package. Seriously, anyone that could get a streak with the specialist package in FFA was guaranteed to win. So, yeah. Specialist + FFA is what made this game for me. 3. Ghosts A lot of people say this game was bad, and I can kinda see where they're coming from. As a CoD game, it's bad. As a game in general, it's quite decent. The campaign was horrible. The only redeeming factor about it is doge. wow Other than that, Extinction was fun and interesting, and the multiplayer was pretty on point. A lot of people say the maps were horrible, but to me they were great. Big maps led to being able to snipe properly for once since Black Ops (or MW2 even and the gun balance was great (again, outside of shotguns but even they weren't all that bad). 4. MW2 This is probably the pinnacle of CoD MP. Even the shotguns were good. Obviously, due to the issues that happened within Infinity Ward, it didn't see its max potential. Which is unfortunate, to say the least. 5. AW This game is the stinker in the list for me. It was quite possibly my worst experience for a CoD game. Exo suits were a step in the right direction (with Treyarch seemingly fine tuning the idea for BO3). The gun balance was awful, the maps were awful and small, and as a consequence the spawns were awful too. Exo Zombies was kinda fun, I guess. This is the only CoD game I took a break from and never came back to. I pretty much moved to PC and played a lot of TF2, TERA, and Smite. Also the large push on micro-transactions and weapons that can only be unlocked from Supply Drops are there too, which creates another large push on buying Advanced Supply Drops. |
|
|
|
Post by ChloeB42 (Alexcalibur42) on Oct 22, 2015 9:21:43 GMT -5
Just delete it and repost in hey guy cant do that when someone else posts Really? That's silly. Well might as well play along. Judging from Multiplayer only 1. BO2. The maps were good enough overall, with DLC maps having a stark improvement imo. The flow of movement was predictable and controlled for the most part. Most guns were usable after some buffs and nerfs, though not all were called for. Snipers were balanced enough, honestly didn't like anything other than the Ballista though, the DSR's default reticle and slow rate of fire didn't sit right with me. The KSG was good and the 870 was usable enough. Loved the MMS, favorite reticle of any game. Higher FOV, ability to see through smoke and see through walls and it was so underused. Loved the focus on objectives and the very objective friendly scorestreaks like the Sentry and Guardian. Also Theater Mode. 2. BO1, the gun balance was terrible, the perks were terribly balanced, the vast majority of them were garbage. The hit detection was wonky, the snipers were terrible, overall it wasn't a good game. But I loved the maps, I loved the cold war/Vietnam era weapons. The whole equipment, lethal and tactical grenade system was great. The equipment itself was fun, camera spike, decoy grenades, jammer and motion sensor. The combat record is to date the best combat record of any CoD, hopefully BO3 brings back the heat map and ability to compare friends. The introduction of theater Mode and wager matches were a fun addition as well. Plus the interactive parts of some maps were fun as well. 3. Mw3. I hated this game, but looking back I did enjoy it to some degree. I loved the scorestreak system, loved specialist, loved the FAD, some maps were good, the shotguns decent, the snipers decent. But most of my fun was playing hardcore games with my friend and making the enemy team rage so hard with constant grenade launcher spam and holding down key check points. Terrible game though, but had fun to some extent. 4. W@W. Didn't play this until it was a hacked mess and no one really played anymore. But I love the WW2 setting and the bolt-action rifles without a scope. Can't say too much because it's hacked to shit. 5. Mw2, also a late play. I like the gameplay a bit more than W@W, but it had way too many annoying things, I didn't like the maps overall. It's a game that's too easy to do well in. 6. CoD 4, yet again a late game. It's alright, again too easy to do well imo. 7. Ghosts, the snipers pre nerf were amazing... Uh...yeah that's it. 8. AW, fuck this game. |
|
|
|
Post by Pegasus Actual on Oct 22, 2015 13:01:55 GMT -5
I'll just break them into good, and shit.
Good:
COD
COD:UO
COD2
COD4
MW2
MW3
BO2
BO3 (probably)
Shit:
COD3
WaW
BO
Ghosts
AW
For single player I think I got at least some fun out of most of them. I'll single out COD3 for being really shitty on even single-player though.
|
|
Slick
True Bro
Taking the piss
Posts: 1,015
|
Post by Slick on Oct 22, 2015 21:34:41 GMT -5
1: BO3* - Interesting expanded movement mechanics, character classes(rejack can stay weak though, please), open expanded customization on a level not seen in other CoD's. *Only based on beta experience. 2: MW3 - Really enjoyed this during the game's primetime. OP specialist, Riot Shield fast swap to FMG jump to prone was the best fun to be had with a Riot Shield, interesting maps, $20 season dlc with the hardened edition purchase, and airburst killing loiters and snipers when they couldn't see you was the absolute best thing ever. So underrated in Search. Admittedly, my enjoyment of this game partly ties into the abusive power that Sitrep had, but I enjoyed manipulating people into making mistakes. My best play was in this game, this was my jam. Today, the flaws of the weapon and perk balance would be a hindrance, because of smart players. 3: BO2 - Grief mode in zombies, powerful effective killstreaks, good weapon balance, nice maps and action pacing while keeping boots on the ground, SR71 to roll bad people. There, I said it.  4: MW2 - The game that had the most diverse ways to play, and had the most powerful killstreaks in the series. In a world where it was very hard to boost, the alternate condition, the Tactical Nuke would've been fine. Also, Spas-12. Forever tainted by grenade launchers, and commando. 5: Ghosts - Explosive funsies with launchers and C4. No tac insert, which was a horribly abusive item. Solid game mechanics wise, but was slow paced, and got boring after a while. 6: BO1 - Probably had some of the best maps of the series, introduced polished zombies experience. Meta was pretty awful though. Picking between immunity from sound or radar sweeps from portable radar is one of the worst design choices the series has seen apart from scrub tubing nonsense from MW2. 7: CoD4 - Nostalgia, first CoD, maps like Crash, Overgrown, Broadcast, Strike, and gunshots with bass to them. Seriously, every gun since then has sounded so hollow in comparison. Has aged terribly on console, balance was an unknown concept during development. 8: WaW - Jack Bauer. 9: CoD2 - Made CoD popular, which I'll respect. The weapon balance was a complete joke, however. I played about an hour before losing interest(though this was well past it's primetime). 10: AW* - Nothing good. Weapon RNG loot was an idea I'll never support. I've seen those horror stories of people playing 14+ days and not getting the Elite weapon variants. Hooray for bull shit gimping. Hid ping numbers. Lied about not monetizing drops, movement system said, "3rd party hardware wins, come grape regular controller newbs with boost jumping", uninteresting maps, sound production, janky looking hit detection. *Based on watching Twitch players, I didn't spend 1 second playing AW. 11: Any leftover - congrats on being bested by AW. |
|
wittyscorpion
True Brorange
All warfare is based on deception.
Posts: 8,598
|
Post by wittyscorpion on Oct 23, 2015 16:12:24 GMT -5
BO3 (probably)
BO3 beta
MW3
BO2
Ghosts
AW
|
|
|
|
Post by imrlybord7 on Oct 24, 2015 4:00:04 GMT -5
AW - insanely fun movement, but you do need to use OP variants to have a good time in Core. So I had a good time.
BO2 - about as tight an experience as the old style of CoD could have been.
Every CoD ever - I enjoyed all of em quite a bit. Each had major pros and major cons. Words.
Ghosts - grew on me a lot, but still not nearly enough for me to view it favorably. Hilariously stupid game made by fake game designers.
MW3 - hilariously stupid game made by fake game designers.
|
|
|
|
Post by ChloeB42 (Alexcalibur42) on Oct 24, 2015 4:19:02 GMT -5
How you can call MW3 a game made by a fake studio and not AW, when it's the same damn people is beyond me. Especially because IW was what made MW3 even remotely decent, Sledgehammer knew and continues to know fuck all.
|
|
|
|
Post by mrcongo93 on Oct 24, 2015 13:07:33 GMT -5
1. Black Ops: While the weapon balance wasn't great, this game had the absolute best maps in the series IMO, and it was one of the last games when Shotgunning and Knife Only was still a viable strategy in slayer game modes.
2. Black Ops 2: The maps weren't as good as in BO1, but the weapon balance was much better. The only reason this doesn't take the #1 spot is because it didn't have the option of Unlimited Sprint. Highlights were the Pick 10, allowing me to take nothing but a Shotgun Pistol and just wreak havoc with a Revolver. The Handguns were balanced perfectly, even the "OP" Kap 40 and B23R were still kept in their place by their poor capacities.
3. COD 4: Modern Warfare: Still had great maps, but the balance was kinda iffy, as there were plenty of guns that weren't really worth using compared to their counterparts.
4. Modern Warfare 2: Was a ton of fun at times, but also a massive S*** storm at other times. The weapon balance was pretty decent, but there were so many BS tactics that just killed my enjoyment 70% of the time.
5. Modern Warfare 3: Take everything about MW2, being the good and the bad, and multiply it by 10. The maps were iffy, and the prevalence of Assassin often made tactical loitering the best possible strategy for winning. No unlimited sprint, underpowerd Shotguns, and Assault Rifles s****ing on every class.
6. Advanced Warfare: A decent first attempt, but over time, some major issues started to present themselves. The weapon balance was awful, and the best weapons in the game were hidden behind a veil of luck, which completely screws people over. Then there's the exo boosts, it was supposed to make navigating more useful, but all it ended up doing was making people jump everywhere as well as just get to the highest point on a map and just use mind bullets. It ruined my experience, and as such is only the 2nd COD game I stopped playing before the end of the cycle. The first one was...
7. Ghosts: I stopped playing this 2 months in. The maps were too large, Weapons and Killstreaks were massively unbalanced, the AR's once again S*** on everything, Snipers are able to kill in one hit on 80% of the body, the dog annoyed me, people were tactical loitering abd headglitching behind corners or in bushes everywhere, and there were IED's place around every corner, making you either have to use Blast Shield, or not move at all. I honestly don't know what IW was doing with this game, and I really hope they don't make another one like this.
I didn't play WAW enough to gauge my enjoyment properly, but I definitely think that Ghosts and AW kinda suck now, MW2/3 are still fun despite their problems, and BO1/2/COD4 are the cream of the crop.
|
|
pachiderm
True Bro
Chewing some serious leaves
Posts: 647
|
Post by pachiderm on Oct 26, 2015 18:21:39 GMT -5
Your guys' opinions suck.
1. CoD4
2. MW2
3. BO2
4. Black Ops
5. Ghosts
everything else was terrible
|
|
|
|
Post by LeGitBeeSting on Oct 26, 2015 18:38:20 GMT -5
MW2#1
Booty Calls 4 get an honorable mention.
That is all.
|
|
|
|
Post by kylet357 on Oct 26, 2015 19:38:14 GMT -5
Your guys' opinions suck. 1. CoD4 2. MW2 3. BO2 4. Black Ops 5. Ghosts everything else was terrible And then, here I am. The guy who thinks CoD4 is horrible. |
|
|
|
Post by ChloeB42 (Alexcalibur42) on Oct 26, 2015 20:08:26 GMT -5
Yeah, your opinion sucks.
|
|
pachiderm
True Bro
Chewing some serious leaves
Posts: 647
|
Post by pachiderm on Oct 26, 2015 21:17:16 GMT -5
sucks to suck i guess
|
|
Slick
True Bro
Taking the piss
Posts: 1,015
|
Post by Slick on Oct 27, 2015 1:15:12 GMT -5
|
|
|
|
Post by UrbaneVirtuoso on Oct 27, 2015 1:40:16 GMT -5
Top 3 CoDfishes in my mind...
Modern Warfare 2 - Wins outright for way of diversity and map design. Part of the game's stupidity lent well to it, even. Props to Sandy Ravage for incentivising shotguns and booster hunting; that shit was the stuff of dreams, given reactions.
Black Ops 2 - Scores well up there for longevity and personalization. Spent a damn good chunk of time producing emblems and it'll look no different with BO3's camo designer. Fun streaks, too... then there's the curveball of a non-linear campaign.
World at War - 3arc's bold revisit of WW2 to prosperity. Things overall were improved upon CoD4 and bolt-actions like the Arisaka felt at home -- stuck a bayonet on that bad boy. As well, there was literally gore so things felt visceral as fuck.
|
|
asasa
True Bro
fuck
Posts: 4,255 
|
Post by asasa on Oct 27, 2015 9:02:10 GMT -5
Sorry casuals, as a player with a kdr in the top 5% and snd spm in the top 1%, I regretfully must inform you that your opinions are lesser than mine. The correct opinion is as follows:
1: black ops
2: mw2
3: mw1
4: black ops 2
Else: shit
Advanced warfare: kill yourself
|
|
fpsdredd
True Bro
Always working on the FPS metagame
Posts: 495
|
Post by fpsdredd on Oct 27, 2015 13:11:57 GMT -5
1. MW3
2. CoD 2
3. BO3 (maybe)
4. AW
|
|
pachiderm
True Bro
Chewing some serious leaves
Posts: 647
|
Post by pachiderm on Oct 27, 2015 13:12:19 GMT -5
Sorry casuals, as a player with a kdr in the top 5% and snd spm in the top 1% Plebstation doesn't count. |
|
Dumien
True Bro
Black Market Trader
No engrams. Only disappointment.
Posts: 3,292
|
Post by Dumien on Oct 28, 2015 10:04:39 GMT -5
The Recent Beta put BO3 somewhere in the top 3.
MW3
BO1
MW2
CoD4
BO2
Ghosts
AW
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 28, 2015 10:24:17 GMT -5
God-tier
BO2 MW2 (probably BO3 too)
Ok-tier
MW3 WaW
Shit-tier
Ghosts AW BO1
Banned-tier
COD4
COD4 sucks because I can't find a server where I can play regularly without getting banned by admins.
|
|
|
|
Post by UrbaneVirtuoso on Oct 28, 2015 10:41:30 GMT -5
Come to think of it, doesn't WaW have dedicated on Steam? Ought of get into that again~.
|
|
asasa
True Bro
fuck
Posts: 4,255
|
Post by asasa on Oct 28, 2015 11:07:01 GMT -5
Sorry casuals, as a player with a kdr in the top 5% and snd spm in the top 1% Plebstation doesn't count. It is with regret that I inform you Sir MLG PRO aSASa has deemed your opinion on PlayStation to be of little or no value. His majesty confirms that PlayStation players are "the best" and you are a "faggot camper". In addition he considered an offer for 1v1 railguns but it was deemed to be too violent as you would be raped harder than his 8 inch cock is hard erect. |
|
PSIII
True Bro
Is a Contender
Posts: 275
|
Post by PSIII on Oct 28, 2015 13:37:47 GMT -5
High:
MW2 - God
CoD4 - Demi-God
MW3 - Prophet
Average:
CoD2 -Honestly it's high, but not better than the MW series. IW just got better even after this.
Ghosts -Decent I guess and functional, but shallow and boring. Lacks any real identity. Weird designs/decisions in the MP aspect.
Low:
Anything made by Treyarch. Will BO3 change that? We'll see.
AW -Sorry Sledgehammer, but AW is easily the worst in the series.
In summary. IW was amazing. Treyarch sucks. Sledgehammer probably sucks. Activision sucks. IW is slipping. CoD sucks. Miss old days. Etc, etc.
|
|
|
|
Post by RainbowCrash on Oct 28, 2015 17:30:45 GMT -5
BO2: Only COD to keep my interest through the whole cycle and still worth playing today. Above average gun balance and map design. Brilliant soundscape, emblem editor
MW2: one patch away from being perfect, huge nostalgia factor
COD4: >insert line we already know<
AW: I enjoyed the innovation, but after a while I got very disgusted with SG milking supply drop sales to death, and the fact I had every challenge completed except for the next to impossible launcher challenges.
BO1: it was okay
Ghosts: MEH - I liked some of the maps though. personally I think the dry dusty color scheme was a huge part of its dislike.
MW3: basically MW2.5 in my eyes, map design was meh
NOTE: didn't play Cod1-3 and WaW, BO3 is projected 1 or 2
|
|
pachiderm
True Bro
Chewing some serious leaves
Posts: 647
|
Post by pachiderm on Oct 28, 2015 18:31:37 GMT -5
Plebstation doesn't count. It is with regret that I inform you Sir MLG PRO aSASa has deemed your opinion on PlayStation to be of little or no value. His majesty confirms that PlayStation players are "the best" and you are a "faggot camper". In addition he considered an offer for 1v1 railguns but it was deemed to be too violent as you would be raped harder than his 8 inch cock is hard erect. U wot. I'll rek u m8 |
|
prioc
True Bro
eep
Posts: 235
|
Post by prioc on Oct 29, 2015 13:13:15 GMT -5
1. AW - Probably the most fun I've had on a game in a while. I think the movement system is really cool and fun. The only thing I don't really like is that some guns are too weak, and the variants could have been implemented in a better way. I agree with banana about the shotguns + snipers, but I think if you get good with them and use the right setups, they're fine. The game's art style is pretty cool too
2. MW3 - I really like all of the weapons and perks. I think some of the machine pistols and the MP7 are too strong, otherwise everything else seems fine to me. It feels a lot like a MW2 expansion, but I liked MW2 a lot. The only thing that I really like more from MW2 are the maps, but I think most of MW3's maps are good enough.
3. BO2 + MW2 - It's hard to say which one I like more, but I'm a lot better at BO2. I think both games' killstreaks are too strong though. MW2 definitely has better maps, but I think I like BO2's weapons more.
4. BO1 + CoD4 - I didn't play CoD4 until after BO2 came out and I bought BO1 when Ghosts came out, and didn't really play either that much. I think they're both pretty good, but I'd probably rather play one of the other games if I wanted "classic" CoD.
I didn't play any of the other games, so I'm not sure about them.
|
|
|
|
Post by illram on Nov 1, 2015 13:04:46 GMT -5
1. MW2
2. MW1
3. MW3/BO1
4. BO1/MW3
5. all the rest. The different levels of good/bad are meaningless to me because none of BO2/Ghosts/AW "scratch the itch" the way the above do. If I had to rank the worst it would be AW. Honestly if Ghosts had players I would probably prefer it to BO2. I know, sacrilege. (I never played world at war.)
For me, the original formula was great. It's a testament to how good the first Modern Warfare was, really. With just minor tweaks on that formula (MW2), they could keep an amazing game going. And MW3 was basically just MW2 but with worse maps. This coincided with when IW fractured and lost a lot of talent, and Treyarch--usually second fiddle to IW--became the new "old veteran" of the COD franchise annual reboot. The rest is history.
I want a MW2 remaster for Xbone! Include the DLC maps and I'd pay full ticket price for admission to that dance. Do it Activision.
|
|
